For U.S.-based startups, tax season is a nearly universal pain point. That’s why Puzzle has put together the comprehensive guide to tax season for founders

For U.S.-based startups, tax season is a nearly universal pain point.
That’s why Puzzle has put together the full guide to tax season for founders, complete with experts explaining almost everything you need to file easily and accurately.
Below, Luke Frye, CPA, our own Head of Customer Success at Puzzle, provides his insights into:
“It may be a cliché, but taxes are inevitable. The longer you wait to deal with them, the worse it’s going to get for your startup. If you’re not staying on top of things, enlist the help of tools like Puzzle or hire supportive professionals.”
TLDR:
With startup taxes, you can build from the beginning with the end in mind.
Without accurate financial records, how can you expect a smooth and compliant tax return?
So, here are three financial habits you can instill to help your startup conquer tax season, instead of the other way around.

Startups at their earliest stages are frequently made up of a group of friends. It makes sense that no one thinks to put a legitimate payroll in place. (And, funnily enough, many founders forget to put themselves on payroll even after it’s set up.)
However, this is one critical step toward being legitimized as a company.
Founders often charge business expenses to their personal cards. These purchases also need to be put on the books. After all, accounting for everything will keep your records clean.
Ideally, you should reimburse yourself once a month under an accountable plan. This approach is “penny for penny,” says Luke, as opposed to a stipend, which would be taxable.
To avoid this headache entirely, you can also:
In the grand scheme of things, Luke recommends hiring a tax accountant as soon as you’ve finalized your incorporation.
In terms of preparing for tax season, he encourages every founder to locate an accountant, get in contact, sign a contract, and perhaps even pay them before the year’s end. Luke has seen that waiting until March often means the best accountants are already booked.
Overall, do not wait until you need a tax accountant. By then, it’ll likely be an emergency.
To find a vetted tax accountant who caters to startups, check out this directory by Puzzle.
“It’s frankly a garbage-in, garbage-out situation. If you have a haphazard accounting system, the quality of your tax return just will not be higher than the subpar quality of your bookkeeping.”
As a startup, your goal should be deploying as efficiently as possible, both in terms of dollars and human effort. This is especially the case for those who’ve raised capital.
For tax season, it is simply far more efficient and effective to bring on a professional.
Here are three reasons why.
Luke acknowledges it can seem cheaper upfront for pre-seed and seed-stage ventures to DIY their finances.
After all, everyone is trying to minimize burn in current market environments, and services like, say, Stripe Atlas are cheaper than hiring a lawyer.
However, those immediate gains will not measure up to the big-picture returns driven by accountants with years of experience in maximizing savings. A founder’s basic financial education just does not compare.
In the rare case that you’re a founder who doubles as a highly efficient bookkeeper, you may be able to manually handle your company’s taxes. Or, with software like Puzzle keeping your books clean, you can get partway there.
Once your startup seriously begins to scale, you, the founder, need to be out of the weeds. You want to be logging in to check relevant financials, not matching transactions.
If you’re a diligent and self-educated founder or CFO, you may go searching for resources online and find some pretty legit instructions, such as an IRS article.
While it may provide insights, the reality is: Online content is not the law. Tax codes and regulations are an entirely separate beast, best understood by accountants.
In the meantime, what are some reliable resources? Luke recommends two:
“I would not DIY all of your finances. For instance, if you DIY your bookkeeping, I highly encourage you to use a tax accountant, no matter what. Get at least one professional on your side to catch things you just don’t know about.”
The best accountants have spent years on the job, building up niche know-how and shortcuts. Founders rarely hear these tips in time because many don't talk to an accountant until March, when, as Luke has seen, the best ones are already booked.
Here are three high-value tax secrets that they love to pass on to startup founders.
| Secret | Key Action | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Always extend your tax return | File for a six-month extension every year (deadline moves to Oct 15) | Unlocks the option to file a superseded return instead of a costly amended one |
| Claim the R&D tax credit | Document salaries for engineers, designers, and product roles | Qualifying startups can offset up to $500,000 a year of payroll taxes, even with zero net income, and may be able to claim prior years |
| Accountants work on FIFO | Get your books to your accountant early and respond to emails fast | First in, first filed: slow replies send you to the back of the queue |
It’s best practice to extend your tax return deadline every single year for two reasons.
For example, say you requested an extension in February and still filed your return by March. However, by May, you found new info that required you to correct your filings and properly account for your carry-forward loss.
Instead of filing an amended tax return, which is far more tedious and expensive, you can file a superseded tax return by your extended due date.
One such opportunity is the R&D tax credit, which Luke calls “basically free money.”
If you fund U.S.-based research and development, which technically includes paying salaries for engineers, designers, and any similar positions that develop products, the IRS can provide a credit against your payroll tax.
To use the payroll tax offset, your startup must be a qualified small business: less than $5 million in gross receipts for the tax year, and no gross receipts before the five-year period ending with that year, according to the IRS.
Also note that the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, restored immediate deductions for domestic research and experimental costs (including software development) under Section 174A, for tax years beginning after December 31, 2024, as Thomson Reuters explains. Ask your tax accountant how that interacts with your credit.
But here’s why this tax credit is especially impactful:
Even if you’ve overlooked this credit in the past, you may be able to get it refunded retroactively.
Accountants often execute work on a FIFO (“first in, first out”) basis. That means if you get your books to your accountant first, you’ll likely be filed first.

However, Luke also notes that email is where requests tend to get lost during busy season.
If you have their attention, respond as quickly as possible to keep it. Otherwise, waiting a day or two to reply may mean ending up back at the bottom of the stack.
“When it comes to communicating with your tax accountant, keep yourself top of mind and provide them with clear deadlines.”
Getting to the front of your accountant's queue only pays off if you bring the right questions, and a few recent R&D tax changes belong on that list. With less than two months left in 2026, they are worth raising before year-end.
Immediate R&D expensing is now the default. Section 174A, added by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, lets you deduct domestic research costs (software development counts) in the year you pay them, for tax years beginning after December 31, 2024. The IRS laid out the election procedures in Rev. Proc. 2025-28, including an option to amortize over at least 60 months instead. That choice is made with your return, so settle it with your accountant before filing.
The retroactive window for 2022 to 2024 has closed. Eligible small businesses had until July 6, 2026 (or the close of each year's refund-claim window, if earlier) to amend earlier returns and apply the new rules to research costs you were required to amortize in those years, as Rev. Proc. 2025-28 sets out. If you missed it, ask whether any remaining unamortized balance can still be deducted on your 2026 return.
Form 6765 asks for more detail. The revised form adds business component reporting in Section G, which covers the projects behind your claim and the people who worked on them. Section G is mandatory for tax years beginning after 2025, so it applies to your 2026 return. Qualified small businesses that elect the payroll tax credit are exempt under the IRS instructions for Form 6765, so confirm with your accountant whether it applies to you. Either way, start noting now which engineers and designers worked on which projects.
One more reason to extend every year: the payroll tax election has to be made on an original, timely filed return. The IRS guidance on the payroll tax credit explains the rules, and an amended return cannot add the election later.
Yes. File the extension regardless of how clean your books are. The real value is unlocking the superseded return option: if new information surfaces after you file (like a carry-forward loss you missed), you can correct it before the extended deadline instead of filing a costly amended return.
Qualified small businesses with less than $5 million in gross receipts can apply up to $500,000 per year of the R&D tax credit against payroll taxes, even with zero net income. That means salaries paid to engineers, designers, and product roles may generate a real cash offset on payroll taxes your startup is already paying, and you may be able to claim prior years retroactively.
Reimburse yourself once a month under an accountable plan, which is reimbursed dollar-for-dollar and not taxable, unlike a stipend. The cleaner approach is to separate business and personal finances from day one under your EIN, so those transactions flow directly into your books.
Hire one as soon as you finalize incorporation, and lock in a contract before year-end. The best startup-focused tax accountants are often fully booked by March, so waiting until you actually need to file puts you at the back of the queue or leaves you with whoever is still available.
Puzzle automates about 90% of transaction categorization and keeps your books updated daily, so your records are clean before tax season starts instead of reconstructed during it. Puzzle also maintains a vetted accountant directory built for startups, but does not provide tax services itself. For filing and R&D credit work, you need a dedicated tax accountant working from accurate books.
It depends on how far behind you are. If you are a month or two behind and most transactions are already categorized, you can finish them yourself. If you are many months behind, or the deadline is close, hand the catch-up work to a bookkeeper.
Puzzle's catch-up bookkeeping starts at $300 per month of books, so 11 months behind is $3,300, and it requires an active Puzzle software subscription. Timing depends on how many months need work and how fast you answer questions, so loop in your tax accountant at the same time and send clean books as early as you can.
Puzzle drafts categorization and reconciliations during the month and flags exceptions early, so you review the work instead of rebuilding it at period end. About 90% of transactions are categorized automatically and about 85% are finalized, and founders typically spend 15 to 20 minutes a week approving the rest. If you are already months behind, pair the software with catch-up bookkeeping so your accountant receives finished books well before the filing date.
Yes. Puzzle is an AI-native accounting firm, so services run on the same ledger as the software, but they are a separate add-on to your software plan. Expert Reviewed starts at $99 per month per entity (Core plus Expert Reviewed is $171 per month): the AI suite does the work and a bookkeeper reviews, corrects, and closes your books every month, with up to three bookkeeping questions per month. It fits one entity and one accounting basis with up to $10K in monthly expenses and no payroll processing, AP/AR, or inventory. Full Service starts at $499 per month per entity, priced by monthly expenses: a named bookkeeper runs the full monthly close, answers unlimited bookkeeping questions by email, and sends a month-end summary. Bookkeepers are Puzzle accountants or vetted partner firms, and you approve every month. Neither tier includes tax filing.
Cash position, P&L, and balance sheet update daily, along with burn rate, ARR/MRR, runway, and cash on hand. Instead of waiting on your bookkeeper for a monthly package, you open Puzzle and see where cash stands, how fast you are spending, and how many months of runway remain before you make a hiring or spending call. If you add a bookkeeper, they work in the same ledger, so you and your bookkeeper see the same numbers.
You need your own CPA or tax accountant for filing, because Puzzle does not provide tax services. Puzzle's role is the books: accurate, up-to-date records your accountant can file from, so they are not reconstructing your year in March. For a place to start your search, use Puzzle's vetted accountant directory built for startups, and sign a contract before year-end.
Switch when the weekly 15 to 20 minutes of transaction review keeps slipping, when you fall more than a month behind, or when you are preparing for a fundraise or investor reporting. With one entity and under $10K in monthly expenses, Expert Reviewed bookkeeping is the natural first step. Move to Full Service when you add payroll processing, AP/AR, or higher spend and want a named bookkeeper running the close.
No. Puzzle supports USD and US entities only, so there is no multi-currency accounting. Its workflows are built for US startups (Delaware C-Corps in particular), and it is not set up for accounting or tax rules in the UK, EU, or other countries. If you run a foreign entity or book transactions in other currencies, you need a different tool for that entity and a local accountant. Puzzle does not provide tax services either, so confirm your filing requirements with your own tax accountant.





